Federal Defenders of New York Second Circuit Blog

Yuanchung Lee

Yet Another Courtroom Closure Case

by

Yung v. Walker, Docket No. 03-3023-pr (2d Cir. Oct. 31, 2006) (Pooler, Sotomayor, Kaplan): This is but the most recent iteration of a long and tedious line of habeas cases in which the petitioner claims that his Sixth Amendment public trial right was violated when the New York state trial judge, at the prosecutor’s request, … Read more

Bad Crimes Make Bad Law: Circuit Misreads Rule 404(b) and Uses Junk Science to Link Possession of Child Porn to Actual Illicit Sex

by

United States v. Brand, Docket No. 05-4155-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 19, 2006) (Miner, Wesley, Friedman): It appears that child sex cases have surpassed drug cases in their ability to create bad law and erode civil liberties. We saw in last year’s “Candyman” cases an erosion of the Fourth Amendment’s probable cause requirement; in Brand, we … Read more

Appellate Remand that Requires Solely Ministerial Act by District Court Does Not Toll Finality Clock

by

Stanley Burrell v. United States, Docket No. 05-2945-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 18, 2006) (Cardamone, Walker, Sotomayor): This is a real snoozer; the Court narrowly holds that when it affirms a conviction and sentence but remands the case to the district court to perform a purely ministerial act (here, vacatur of one of two counts of … Read more

Which Version of Pereira Should We Follow?

by

Just to beat this issue completely to death: The version of Pereira that currently appears on Westlaw (United States v. Pereira, ___ F.3d ___, 2006 WL 2925642 (2d Cir. Oct. 13, 2006)), is the first version, in which the Court forgot its own decision in Mejia, rather than the later, corrected one. Anyone want to … Read more

Circuit Silently Changes Decision

by

United States v. Pereira, Docket No. 05-5969-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 13, 2006): Sometime this morning, the Circuit altered its original opinion in this case, which as this Blog pointed out (see entry below) somehow forgot about its own decision in Mejia. The opinion now simply rejects Pereira’s fast-track disparity argument with a one-sentence cite to … Read more

Judges Are Always the Last to Know: Circuit Forgets Its Own Decision Rejecting Fast-Track Disparity Argument in Illegal Reentry Cases

by

United States v. Marvin Pereira, Docket No. 05-5969-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 13, 2006) (Miner, Leval, Calabresi): We had to do a double-take at the publication date of this opinion after reading it. Here’s why. Pereira argued on appeal (though he did not do so in the district court) that his 62-month sentence for unlawful reentry … Read more

Concealment Element of Money Laundering Statute Satisfied by Showing that Defendant Hid Identity of Transported Cash

by

United States v. Samuel Ness, Docket No. 05-4401-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 10, 2006) (Winter, Calabresi, Pooler): This decision confirms a split among the Circuits concerning the meaning of the concealment element of the “transaction” and “transportation” money laundering statutes, 18 U.S.C. § 1956(a)(1)(B)(i) & (1)(2)(B)(i). Specifically, while some Circuits have ruled that the defendant has … Read more

“Endeavoring” to Obstruct On-Going Investigation Same as Obstructing Investigation for Guidelines Purposes

by

United States v. Giovanelli, Docket No. 04-5763-cr (2d Cir. Sep. 27, 2006) (Calabresi, Pooler, Parker) (per curiam): This opinion principally holds that when a defendant is constructed of “endeavoring” to obstruct an on-going criminal investigation (here, by passing secret grand jury information to a target of the investigation) under 18 U.S.C. § 1503’s “omnibus” clause, … Read more